
modelH Business Model Canvas: Externalities
Externalities are the external forces and regulations imposed on a business model. This was the most debated block in our 2013 forum. Strict canvas purists said the external environment belongs in strategy, not in a business model. They had a point, and Osterwalder himself argued competition is not part of your business model. Others in the community argued we were over-engineering the thing.
I kept it, using two tests. Does the block affect the business model? Is it needed to explain how the model works? In healthcare, an FDA decision or a CMS rule can make or break a business. Eleven years later, I am more convinced.
Questions for the Externalities Block
- What Externalities put constraints on your business model?
- How do they restrict your Buyers and Users?
- How do they affect your User's Key Behaviors?
- How do they affect your Key Influencers?
- How do they drive Costs?
- How can they be turned into Revenue streams?
Examples from Recent Years
- Drug pricing. The Inflation Reduction Act gave Medicare the power to negotiate certain drug prices, which changes the economics behind many life sciences models.
- Prior authorization. CMS finalized a rule in January 2024 requiring impacted payers to speed up decisions and build new data-sharing APIs. Mandates like this create buyers with deadlines.
- Medicare Advantage. CMS's 2024 rule on broker compensation shows how quickly a Channel's economics can come under scrutiny.
- Shocks. A pandemic changed telehealth rules almost overnight, and a cyberattack on Change Healthcare disrupted payments nationwide. Not every external force arrives through a rule.
Turning Externalities into Advantage
My favorite question on this block is the last: how can they be turned into Revenue?
- Regulatory clearance can be a moat when competitors have not done the work.
- Real-world evidence requirements favor those who already collect it.
- Compliance can be a product, as with audit trails and governance tools.
- New mandates create buyers with deadlines.
Regulation cuts both ways. A rule that protects you today can be reversed tomorrow, so do not build your whole model on one rule.
What is Next?
We wrap up the How Much.
to your health,
Kevin

